Delimitation without census pointless

Much has been said about delimitation of Karachi but the controversy seems to gaining pace.  Election commission is all set to conduct house to house voter’s verification and somehow preparing to review the delimitation of constituencies in Karachi as well. Though in his recent statement ECP chairman in his “personal opinion” supported MQM’s stance and said that once delimitation is conducted after the census, then delimiting those constituencies again without holding a new census is “pointless.”

It is pertinent to mention that on Nov 26, a five-member bench of the apex court had observed that constituencies in Karachi should be delimited in a manner that they comprise “mixed population” to avoid political polarization.

And later on Dec 20, The Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) had virtually isolated itself from other political parties when it opposed the issue at a meeting in which Election Commission had convened in this regard. MQM as a result decided to convince Supreme court on legal grounds.

At this point of time the people of Karachi seems confused about Supreme courts decision of delimiting Karachi only as population census are held in different countries of the world before the redrawing of constituencies and then demarcation of constituencies is carried out. On what legal grounds delimitation would take place is still a question to be answered by the Law hawks.

Not to mention that the election commission’s decision to review constituencies of Karachi only and that too without census can open a Pandora box.

As ECP reports for the General Elections 2002 gives province wise break down of complaints. According to the report, total 97 complaints were filed from Balochistan, 238 from Sindh and 165 from Khyberpakhtunkhwa, these statistics roughly indicate that there was nothing extraordinary raised against the ‘delimitation’ of the province.

Also, Pashtuns living in Balochistan have long contended  that their number was not accurately recorded in 1998 population census as they had boycotted the census hence they are underrepresented. Likewise Karachi can also demand greater number of seats as a result of mass migration from up country during the recent years.

Karachites also ask whether Election commission would reduce seats from KP, Balochistan and Punjab and allocate those seats to the metropolis since most of the people moved to Karachi from these provinces in recent years.

When would Honorable Supreme Court enforce other parts of judgment where it said that land should be recovered occupied illegally is another question being pondered by the citizens of Karachi, as implementation of this particular judgment would bar illegal occupants living illegally in the outskirts of Karachi as well as on the mountains from manipulating the voting lists, using land illegally, stealing electricity and other resources being utilized without paying taxes.

Contrary to the current situation, just a few years ago the Election commission of Pakistan in its press release on May 23, 2007 had taken a very clear position against delimitation of constituencies in the absence of new population census.

This is the position which Election commission respectfully needs to communicate with the Honorable court as demands for delimitation could also be raised from other cities of Pakistan and it would be irrational to believe that except Karachi rest of the country’s constituencies were perfectly drawn.

In my opinion Karachi should not be given “priority” on any other city of Pakistan. Along with Karachi, delimitation of other cities should also be carried out as per “law” because without a fresh census, the act of delimitation, which in essence is meant to create equality in the constituencies, would be nothing but a futile exercise.



  1. Got to agree with this reasonable and well written piece. Good job Tanzeel! I’d want to add my point of view on “delimitation” issue. I’ve nothing against it except why his uegency here and why Karachi centric? Is it not a contitutional requirement to have census before delimitation of constituencies? If it is then let’s wait and have census first and let’s not do delimitation in Karachi or Hyderabad only simply because MQM is popular among the populace in these constituencies. You, or even the Supreme Court and its judges, can not bulldoze a people’s will and right to choose. MQM and its leadership is popular because the people want and support them and wish them to lead and represent them.

    1. Thanks but now things have gone beyond delimitation. We are expecting something big in future. What do you think is going to happen on 14th Jan.

      1. Have to agree with you. Things have indeed taken a new turn. Yes, we are and should expect bigger things and hope with better results. In my view, January 14 is going to be the day which would become most significant alongwith August 14 in Pakistan. On August 14 the country got its independance and January 14 would be the day when Pakistni people would finally become free. Our forefathers before us and we after them have waited for this day which is about to happen. From then on we all, irrespective of our economic status, would have a say in a truly representative democracy here which guarantees equal rights and opportunities to pursue our dreams and aspirations. I’m hoping that those few who are resisting this movement would come along and agree that Pakistan was not created for any sham democracy where afew would rule the lot, it’s not created protect God (Naooz-o-Billah) but to protect and provide for all Pakistanis without any descrimination on he basis of ethinicity or religious thoughts. Either we would have it peacefully, which is best for us all, or we would have it after taking it on our bodies, but then a few dozens or score or hundered or evn thousands of our lives are worth the cause. In my view the aliance of Qadri & MQM would achieve for Pakistan what the rest of the gangsters denied us for so long. I see, Imran Khan joining and taking advantage of the situation which is just fine as there are more commonalities among us here than those feudals and the rest of the gangs of rulers so far. Let’s hope for the best.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s